Rate The Sig Above You Thread!

[Greyfang]

Nice concept on that sig, nicely built (regarding comboing well the text and pic)... but i just can't ignore the sig imagesize. Seems like it would be an avatar rather than a sig. Might be even better with the text in sig and pic in avatar (as a combo, not as a "sig" since this thread only concerns that).

7/10

i give your sig a 6/10, but -1 for having to click to see it.

[jasmo]

i give your sig a 6/10, but -1 for having to click to see it.

I was trying to get it to show and in the middle of it changed it a couple of times... so which one were you talking about?

I give you a 8/10 :)

http://koti.mbnet.fi/vaikkapa/Jasmon/jasmofog.jpg
or
http://koti.mbnet.fi/vaikkapa/Jasmon/darkfall/mahrim_sig.jpg

btw, why wont they show with [img] tags? Feeling kinda dumb (and lazy) for not figuring it out myself...:bang:

[bennne]

btw, why wont they show with [img] tags? Feeling kinda dumb (and lazy) for not figuring it out myself...:bang:

Because you upload to their own servers.. just press the Upload signature button in the User CP :P

[Rili]

Nice sig, tho you should try to blend the Dwarf abit more, try some color filters ?

7/10

[Temet nosce]

Nice sig, tho you should try to blend the Dwarf abit more, try some color filters ?

7/10

8/10, excellent use of light in melding the character with the background, but the text is clearly copy pasted onto the picture, doesn't fit at all. Fix that and it'd be a ten.

[Lachrymose]

8/10, excellent use of light in melding the character with the background, but the text is clearly copy pasted onto the picture, doesn't fit at all. Fix that and it'd be a ten.
6/10. i can barely read the writing, and the background seems messy. although it still looks kinda cool in an abstract way. if you changed the font, it would probably look much better.

[Slavas]

8/10

[Lycidious]

6/10

[Black Thunder]

6/10

[Razli]

Okay I suppose. Its a clan sig. Pretty standard. 7/10

[Siria Cessmera]

8/10 - only real drawback is that the text "humble" looks like "numble", unless you meant for that.

http://www.thesunderedguard.com/images/sigs/ashiria.gif

[Black Thunder]

7.5/10

[Razli]

8/10 - only real drawback is that the text "humble" looks like "numble", unless you meant for that.

http://www.thesunderedguard.com/images/sigs/ashiria.gif

Lol, No I did not. Someone else brought that up. If one of the Hearlds of the Duchy want to give our Tewdric a ding a ling and tell him to fix it, thatd be great. Or another new sig while your at it.

And....Yours a 8/10, I like it, yet it is simple. Woah, it jsut changed...10/10 for coolness. Sadly cant be sued for a sig. Im thinking Devs should allow Gif sigs. They are usually kick ass.

[jasmo]

Knowledge is power...

The sig is very nice 8.5/10, the old font doesn't bother me at all.

Now my sig should be fixed also... if it doesn't show here, check back a page :)

[DarkCrusader]

7.0 I see it on the other page but this one.........:cool:

[[O]_Fawkes]

7.0 I see it on the other page but this one.........:cool:

I like it.

Good use of contrast with the background and all.
8/10

When somebody rates my signature can you give me more specific criticism. As in where do I need more or less shadows, color, etc.?

I've been looking at this as a puzzle and not the finished product for three days so I really can't tell what's wrong with it besides that there's something wrong with it.

[Brakkish]

_Fawkes;2386868']
When somebody rates my signature can you give me more specific criticism. As in where do I need more or less shadows, color, etc.?

I've been looking at this as a puzzle and not the finished product for three days so I really can't tell what's wrong with it besides that there's something wrong with it.



7/10 - the right border would give it a more "finished" look imo. :)

Here's an example

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c13/mikkhammerfist/Untitled-1-1.jpg

And here's a real "Mac" looking version.

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c13/mikkhammerfist/Untitled-2.jpg

[Freyr]

Not really my style but I'd say 7/10, it's very unique with lots of info. I don't really like how you flipped the picture though, just looks really weird to me.

[covo]

7/10 I like the feel.

[Megumi]

7/10 I like the feel.

3/10 hate it. hate it. hate it.

[DarkCrusader]

6.5 dont like the quote the sig is a bit small and has no border nice font though.........:D

[Megumi]

6.5 dont like the quote the sig is a bit small and has no border nice font though.........:D

9.

Prefer it to the old one.

if you wanna mod my sig, you're welcome to. Not saying I'll use it though :)

[Azerno]

6

Needs more depth, and less lighting.'m also not a fan of stroked borders for text. more variety in the background would help as well

[Greyfang]

6

Needs more depth, and less lighting.'m also not a fan of stroked borders for text. more variety in the background would help as well

simple yet elegant. 7/10

[ZZ Top]

ho greyfang - i was toying with that wolfpic too. like the overall style, but the "among the shadows" doesnt come across very badass. it's like poeple who point out their puns (http://www.thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=puns) that deducts to a total of 6/10 imho ;)
regards

[Skribbles]

7.5/10
i like the concept but the bloody letters are a bit hard to read at a glance... the tear is nice tho (.5) other than that good sig i like it =)

[taxus]

6 lil to cartoonish for my taste.

[mrbubbles]

5, theres something a little off about your sig, can't name it but it's there.

[Linelor]

2/10

My 99% guess is that you took someone's sig and cut off the bottom as to not show the name.

[Arnbjorn]

By the book standard tutorial-sig, but I love that style. 9/10 for the signature itself. 6/10 for the text, it honestly destroys that sig which could be beyond awesome.

A suggestion is to use more basic standard font and perhaps fit color better. And whatever you do dont apply those standard effects on the text destroying the simplicity.

And text placement, try placing the text closer to the render, it would emphasize the signature a bit more making it less dull and bringing out a certain feeling a lot more.

[Smallpox]

6/10

nice scream of desperation

[Arnbjorn]

6.5/10

Way too emo for me, and ugly red color.

[Lycidious]

7.2/10

if you can bevel that dudes face, make it pop off the screen it would be a lot tighter.

(some minor editing on mine)

[SekZ]

I like it... nice lettering and good choice of colors.

[bennne]

AMAZING Spolir ftw! 10/10!

[DarkCrusader]

7.9 Dont like the font and dont see a border.Cartoon render with real back ground doesnt always work looks good in your sig......:cool:

[Cyanhide]

here goes mine xD

[Greyfang]

here goes mine xD

first of all, this is the "Rate the Sig Above You Thread," which you didn't do... guess you're in too big a hurry to show off this collection of ass. which, second of all, has nothing to do with Darkfall and took little effort on your part to turn into a sig.

so, 3/10 (1 for each ass) - 1 for not rating the sig above you.

2/10.

[Cyanhide]

ouch... but good criticisme =) ,I can follow you ...

but i like ass

I do like yours love the background has a furr look... the claws are to much for my taste
and the font is great

overall 8/10

[Black Thunder]

0/100

[DarkCrusader]

first of all, this is the "Rate the Sig Above You Thread," which you didn't do... guess you're in too big a hurry to show off this collection of ass. which, second of all, has nothing to do with Darkfall and took little effort on your part to turn into a sig.

so, 3/10 (1 for each ass) - 1 for not rating the sig above you.

2/10.


Thank you greyfang i was going to say that but you did it before I did.

7.5 For black Thunder love the ork sharpening his weapon....:cool:

[Lycidious]

0/100
that sig deserves 101/100.

/final iteration on mine

[Lather]

7/10 a bit blurry

[Rylemos]

7/10 a bit blurry

8/10

like the color choice

[Chooch]

looks almost 8-bit; 8/10

[Black Thunder]

No signature. D:

that sig deserves 101/100.

I don't like bare asses on my screen.

People who are stupid and quick to assume think that I'm viewing illicit material. :D

[Survivor]

got the right genre for orks and i like the fonts. nice ork to the right, adds some gd humour. altho addmitably it is a little dull and lacks something to make it stand-out

7.5/10 - good overall

[Black Thunder]

6/10 weee paragon

[[O]_Fawkes]

6/10 weee paragon

8/10.

Like the Ork.

Person who rates mine: If you're going to critique it can you tell me what I could do to make it better?

[Zethus]

8/10, could you make the "t"s look more "t-ish"?

[mrbubbles]

3/10
The words are kinda crappy, no background, The picture os okay

[Rili]

Cartoonish =) me like!

8/10

[Peith]

8.5/10

[DarkCrusader]

8.9 Rili is that elf a girl or guy?............:cool:

Peith 8.0 for your sig........like the kid......

[Rili]

8.9 Rili is that elf a girl or guy?............:cool:

Peith 8.0 for your sig........like the kid......

It has boooooobs :P yes its a girl ^^

6/10 the "avatar" dosnt blend well :)

[Skribbles]

It has boooooobs :P yes its a girl ^^

6/10 the "avatar" dosnt blend well :)

looks pro imo... blends well together good coloring and easy to read... nice and clean
9/10

[DarkCrusader]

It has boooooobs :P yes its a girl ^^

6/10 the "avatar" dosnt blend well :)


Lol ok but they are kinda small just had to make sure I was seeing what I was seeing....:cool:

7.0 for skribbles to cartoonish for my taste.......:cool:

[Linelor]

6/10

It's descent.

[megx]

8


:ohno:

[Greyfang]

8


:ohno:

blood and bunnies... original.

4/10.

[JoaoQ]

maihrim however i like the smoke background or whatever it is 7/10

[Razli]

maihrim however i like the smoke background or whatever it is 7/10

Pretty Noice, ...Im stuck on a score. Between a 7 and a 8/10

[Grimstein]

I like that quote in you're signature! 10/10

[ZZ Top]

looks pretty excellent to me. the colours match, the lights blends in very well. the character looks good and even his bow is badass. the frame puts in in a good perspective. i would give it a 10/10 but due to the fact that you could not decide between 3 fonts i need to deduce half a point. so a final score of 9.5 - still good =)
regards

[Razli]

I like that quote in you're signature! 10/10

Its a real gem.

looks pretty excellent to me. the colours match, the lights blends in very well. the character looks good and even his bow is badass. the frame puts in in a good perspective. i would give it a 10/10 but due to the fact that you could not decide between 3 fonts i need to deduce half a point. so a final score of 9.5 - still good =)
regards


Actually, the top two are the same, jsut ones smaller, but thanks for the proper evaluation of the sig.

Yours, I find is slightly hard to read, but the effect of it is still strong, so 8/10.

[Freyr]

For ZZ- 7/10 If you cold change that peach color to something that fit more with the forums it'd be 9/10.

For Razli- 8/10 I just don't like the clan font you guys use.

[Razli]

Probs could do with a slightly contrastng background, however, saying that, I still like the use of that guy I cant remember the name of.

So still a 9/10. Looks Good, yet simple.

[Daecu]

8/10 only because you didn't put the extra effort into making the part of your render stickign off the sig have the same effects as the part that is on the sig, which kinda defeats the purpose of the style >_< the bottom part looks very nice though.

[Razli]

8/10 only because you didn't put the extra effort into making the part of your render stickign off the sig have the same effects as the part that is on the sig, which kinda defeats the purpose of the style >_< the bottom part looks very nice though.

Wouldnt know about all that stuff, didnt make it. But thanks for the Critisism. Despiteyours having Mr. Chief there, its still a good sig.8/10

[Lahzo]

I say 9. It just looks plain sweet.

[BlueDragoness]

I say 9. It just looks plain sweet.

No signature... so sad... /wrists

[Greyfang]

No signature... so sad... /wrists

the anime female on the right doesn't really go at all with the rest of it, but i've seen worse.

and estrogen =/= gaming skill, although it's poignant that there is an obvious misspelling in your "scientific" statement.

5/10

[Survivor]

its nice but it seems like all the text fills in the space. would be nice if there was a smaller slash and the text was elsewhere. that way ppl can rly see the background nd stuff which does look gd. The wolf avatar also looks pretty good.

a solid 7.5/10

to my dearest marker : my sig is pretty basic but im aiming for simplicity and at a length abstractism.

[Peith]

6.9/10

Could use a border. Don't really like the font. Dimensions to large for what little is there.

[Skyborn]

6.9/10

Could use a border. Don't really like the font. Dimensions to large for what little is there.

5/10 the concept is funny but that kid looks like he is about to pop a blood vessel and fill his pants.

[ZZ Top]

quite frankly, the concept is really really lame. also a border might add some flair to it right now it just looks cut off. the picture however blends together pretty good, but the guildname is hard to read. overall i give it 6.5 / 10

[Bonney Goatbeard]

1.9/10

[Azerno]

0/10

not funny, and horrible composition

[FermentedLies]

9/10. Needs more contrast.

[DarkCrusader]

8.9 O look I get to rate your sig Muhahaha .............:cool:

[FermentedLies]

8/10. Needs better background, otherwise nice. I'ma bout to get banned.

[Greyfang]

8/10. Needs better background, otherwise nice. I'ma bout to get banned.

heh, so what else is new? :sly:

[xWebb]

7 to fermented. needs a render of some sort. or a background thats easier to see the wolf in.

[ZZ Top]

the font colors doesnt blend well with the background, also you should stick to 2 fonts instead of 3. too much glow overall and give it a frame. atm just a 4/10 from me

[Razli]

8.9 O look I get to rate your sig Muhahaha .............:cool:

Doing the person quoted.

I think its better than your "busy" ones. defo a stong 8/10. Plain but effective.

[stalwart]

+8 for cool sig, -1 for DoW.

7


mine's simple. but effective.

[Cyanhide]

okay your sig is the best one i'v seen so far...they didn't like my butt sig...

i'm loving it ...

[stalwart]

i'm almost positive someone's going to bitch about it, i asked the mods about it, no response yet though.

[Senti]

i'm almost positive someone's going to bitch about it, i asked the mods about it, no response yet though.

I don't mind it.
At least she's not like some of the horrifying girls we get in the Desktop thread.

Edit: 10/10

[Azerno]

7/10 I really like the concept and the use of contrasting colors. However, I feel that something a little more could have been done with the background and the text needs some serious work. The text really throws it off.

[Mad_Cow20]

They all look pretty good!

[Pontjacko]

I most say... 4/10

[megx]

8

[sanemaniac]

10...i would hit that!!! haha

[Peith]

1/10 because you can't be 201% of something. When you're soccer coach said you gave it 110%? He was bullshitting you.

[Achtbar]

1/10 because you can't be 201% of something. When you're soccer coach said you gave it 110%? He was bullshitting you.

8 ..... He was *cry*

[AngryBarrel]

He doesn't have one/10

[UltimateApeBoy]

8

[Temet nosce]

8

You are a fucking moron for not having a sig and posting here/10

[Aknabud]

ultimate ape boy.... 0 bc of your lack of sig


i know mines not that great but ohwell. i dont have adobe paint

[Din]

ultimate ape boy.... 0 bc of your lack of sig


i know mines not that great but ohwell. I dont have adobe paint


3/10- I think the text in the bottom right hand side could be a bit more clear, it's fairly hard to read.

[Koveras]

I could take ur pansy group 4 vs 1.
Change the blue colors to pink, its more fitting!

3/10

[xMistx]

7/10 not because of artistic ability, IF those guys in the pic are his buddies ingame as well,.......???????????????>>>>>>..........ok i am trying to be nice 4/10



Koveras 9/10 nice sig

[Aknabud]

made a new sig...but the text came out shitty...
"...and the rivers ran red with the blood of the innocent..." is what it says. i'll fix it later, gimme some input though THANKS!


btw good job xMistx

[megx]

7

[Wulf]

Only thing I really don't like is the white background. It would be nice to have the same background as the forum or a decent other background; 6,5/10

[Bitterkoekje]

only thing i really don't like is the white background. It would be nice to have the same background as the forum or a decent other background; 6,5/10

8.5/10

[BdFear.Darko]

5/10 the penguins, remove the quotes...

[Camthylion]

4/10

[Aranin]

6/10 its ok but a mix of some other colour/tones would work well imo.

[Aranin]

odd my sig isnt coming up

[Hellz]

Now it is!

Epic sig, 9.5/10 (Im having troubles reading whats under ARANIN :P)...

[Uncletouchme]

Now it is!

Epic sig, 9.5/10 (Im having troubles reading whats under ARANIN :P)...

7/10 it has a likable feel to it - such a happy face. But the background is just to plain. Guess I'm getting used to all these sigs that go Awhhhhhhhhhhh (hands up with light coming down) in the background. It could use a bit more life, but not too much tho could also take away from it to.

[BurningPhoenix]

8 evil, intense, and awsome

[Rili]

Wtf are youg doing with one of my sigs ? remove it at once.

[nitro912gr]

edited, the guy above posted at the same time, so this one takes 8/10 very good.

[Greyfang]

edited, the guy above posted at the same time, so this one takes 8/10 very good.

well, it's green and glowy, but not much to it. however, since you're from Athens, you get +1, but Azeroth negates that with a big -1.

3/10.

[Black Thunder]

6/10

[Curtains]

6/10 the ork isn't orky enough.

What do you think of the cookie?

[Lukelo]

I wish, I wish, I was a fish.

[Temet nosce]

I wish, I wish, I was a fish.

You failed to rate the person above you. That said...

9/10, the white text doesn't quite match the picture and the whiteness surrounding your character stops it from fitting perfectly with the background, but overall an excellent match.

[Skyborn]

You failed to rate the person above you. That said...

9/10, the white text doesn't quite match the picture and the whiteness surrounding your character stops it from fitting perfectly with the background, but overall an excellent match.

I've spent ten minutes trying to figure out what the fuck your sig says Temet...I cannot, therefore 6/10...its sweet otherwise.

[Froed]

8/10

Good, I like the imagery, but I'd go with a shadow over glow for the figure/wings. Lettering is awkward.

[Skyborn]

8/10

Very... intense, with complimentary and well placed lettering. Somewhat illegible, sadly. But that's typical.

I liked the original coloring of your sig better but it still makes me lol for some reason 9/10

[swiftbuster]

I liked the original coloring of your sig better but it still makes me lol for some reason 9/10

Damn,very very nice.

[Whacko]

Damn,very very nice.

7/10

Reminds me of Heavy Metal.......

[Uncletouchme]

7/10

Reminds me of Heavy Metal.......

8.9/10 makes me giggle too much to nit-pick

[Melora]

9/10

Not a fan of the text.

[nitro912gr]

6/10 I don't like the dark background with the lighter girl and bird.

[Villageninja]

6/10 I don't like the dark background with the lighter girl and bird.

9/10 I don't do drugs so I can't really appreciate the hippie-trippy value of this signature but it's nice and distracting.

[Galadrist]

9/10 I don't do drugs so I can't really appreciate the hippie-trippy value of this signature but it's nice and distracting.

5/10

Because a true ninja sig cannot be seen.
(I see yours.)

[Villageninja]

5/10

Because a true ninja sig cannot be seen.
(I see yours.)

Naruto is not a ninja, and ninjas do not dissapear.

8/10 as I can't figure out what the hell that is in your signature (An angry giraffe?) but it's strangely captivating.

[bennne]

The Picture 8/10, as a Signature 1/10

[JonnnyHavoc]

Nice 8/10 pic and sig.

[88Chaz88]

Even though you didn't do it yourself, 9/10 for humour.

[Chipsy]

4/10 i didn't get it :<

[EDIT]I got it after seeing your username , 5/10

[falquador]

Nice one! (Way better then mine :()
I would say 8/10
The Character fits good with the background.

Edit: Im still working on mine

[Chipsy]

I think yours is quite ok, i would give 7/10. Maybee re-do the border, and the text (underlined looks weird to me) and that will be fine ;)

For mine it isn't quite finished yet, i'm wondering if i should add a background of some sort but i like the Dark (Fall) :p

[Rili]

Nice one! (Way better then mine :()
I would say 8/10
The Character fits good with the background.

Edit: Im still working on mine

Prince of persia picture with text. Need moar stuff on it :) 5/10

Oh oh someone replyed before me :P

To the anime girl! 9/10 tho a background with be nice ^^

[Moridinn]

9/10 i like the background and the manner in which the char seems to be in in

[Curtains]

9/10 i like the background and the manner in which the char seems to be in in

Umm, the grey is nice?

[Skyborn]

Umm, the grey is nice?

Umm, the quote is clever?

[Curtains]

Umm, the quote is clever?

There was no sig for me to rate, and you didn't rate mine so double fail.

[Pirate_King]

not intrested in cookies tooday 6/10

[Akuji78]

7/10 anything with werewolves in wins by me

[ShockAI]

Someone's got to give me SOME props for this. lol It's like maybe my second sig ever.

[Arnbjorn]

6/10 but then again I am a rude one.

For your second sig it is really impressive, would beat my second sig by FAR! Great job and it can only get better.

[Mandriane]

http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/6483/signwssz2ca4.jpg

rate this one not the one im using

[Chipsy]

I like it a lot ! 9,5/10 (i can't put 10/10 :p )

Please give me some advices, i did another version of my sig, but i don't really know wich one i prefer ....

So this one?
http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/1134/chipsynanoha2zt6.jpg

Or the one in my actual sig? Or a combination ?

[Greyfang]

Please give me some advices, i did another version of my sig, but i don't really know wich one i prefer .... So this one? Or the one in my actual sig? Or a combination ?

i'm not one for sparkly sigs, but i'm guessing by the image in yours that you are, so the colorful background goes better than the black imo. it could still use a border, but it's not bad. 6.5/10.

[grvitaly]

7,5/10

Nice one.. but not perfect :D

[Koveras]

No sig to rate..

[leontodd]

6

Mine aint really worth rating, and its a little freaky...

[AeFeSS]

Umm, the quote is clever?

10/10. Like this dark art

No sig to rate..
10/10. Nice sig too

[Tendor]

This picture is work in progress and therefore not used in my signature yet. I would be happy if you could rate it anyway. :)

http://www.elucro.com/dump/TTS.png

As the one above me is non-existent, I unfortunately cannot rate it.

[Greyfang]

that's an interesting template, you should have fun working with it. as a background, i'll rate it a 9.5.

[Wolffos]

I like the colors, and the fact that it has a wolf ;) but could use a dynamic background 9/10

[Joshuadude]

great visual! 8/10 im by no means a visual artist so i just have a nice quote :)

[DamunBM]

No picture signature fails -1.3/10

Now behold... photoshopped boobies. Stolen from Stalwart

Orig. Boobies Here:
http://forums.darkfallonline.com/showthread.php?t=74387

[Koveras]

This picture is work in progress and therefore not used in my signature yet. I would be happy if you could rate it anyway. :)

http://www.elucro.com/dump/TTS.png

As the one above me is non-existent, I unfortunately cannot rate it.

It's great and a pretty new template, nice work 8/10
instead of the letters looking like it's sticking out, try the letters sticking in..
inside shadow? not sure what the options are called.

(like the celtic looking art thingy in your background but then with bigger lines or somethign)

[sanemaniac]

8/10 pretty cool

[Greyfang]

8/10 pretty cool

it's alright... looks like you put more work into the font than any other aspect of the sig. 5.5/10.

[DamunBM]

Totally dig the claw ripping thing on the right... 8/10!

[rogersr]

fucking amazing sig 10/10

did you actually make it though?

[DamunBM]

fucking amazing sig 10/10

did you actually make it though?

I like cookies.... 7/10!

I don't know if Stalwart's is real or not, but I just scrubbed his name off there and slapped on my own... So yea, I made mine.

[cliper]

good sig

[Craftblade]

Simple yet spiffy
6/10

[cathal13]

0 i dont se anythng

[Koveras]

Simple yet spiffy
6/10

nice one really 8/10
cepts change the black to the forums grey background color ;)

[SoulJas[RUS]]

7/10 goes to Craftblade

[Haratu]

SoulJas: 7/10
but only cause i seen some awesome ones in other forums

[Greyfang]

SoulJas: 7/10
but only cause i seen some awesome ones in other forums

-1/10 because you just took the quiz today and that's the only sig you're showing.

[Bonney Goatbeard]

6/10

[Kyur]

Blurry, needs border and less green ;), 1/10

My new, Colorful sig :)

[Bonney Goatbeard]

Blurry, needs border and less green ;), 1/10

My new, Colorful sig :)

It's supposed to be green, it's a scary monster, and scary monsters are associated with slimey green.

8/10 Very nice.

[Liquidblade]

I think I know her........................MOM!?!?!?!

[Charliechaos]

7/10 green flaming skulls > red flaming skulls

[Uncletouchme]

7/10 green flaming skulls > red flaming skulls

8/10 i like how the crusader is blended into the background. I kinda get a feeling from it after reading the quote.

[Greyfang]

7/10 green flaming skulls > red flaming skulls

the warrior is nice, the background's alright, but the quote's a bit cliché and the Hyborian font ruins it for me (i'm no fan of AoC). other than that, it's pretty decent. 7.5/10.

edit: bah, if i had a nickel for every time Uncle beat me to a rating, i'd have a few nickels. :sly:

[Uncletouchme]

edit: bah, if i had a nickel for every time Uncle beat me to a rating, i'd have a few nickels. :sly:

Made about 20 cents off ya so far...:D

[Youngbluth]

8/10 the knight in the backround needs some work but all and all its good :D

[Temet nosce]

8/10 the knight in the backround needs some work but all and all its good :D

4/10, the background doesn't fit the character, the text doesn't fit either. None of them are horrible on their own, but they don't go together at all (and actually the background isn't good either way).

[DocGonzo]

4/10, the background doesn't fit the character, the text doesn't fit either. None of them are horrible on their own, but they don't go together at all (and actually the background isn't good either way).

6/10...it's kinda creepy, but wtf man...really... :sly:

[Doomlancer]

4/10

[Bonney Goatbeard]

10/10

[Medieval]

10/10, a positive photo.

[Megumi]

10/10, a positive photo.

4/10 because it makes me think of Drew Carey.

[Winterfresh]

7\10
Font is somewhat blurry and the background is too similar to the character.

[Erendir]

7/10 nice flow and the text, colors, and name all fit the concept, though the text is particularly small...

[GunslingerV]

7/10 nice flow and the text, colors, and name all fit the concept, though the text is particularly small...

7.5/10, cool wolf pic, there's something about the eyes that disturb me though

[ShockAI]

I'm back. With what is roughly my third attempt at a forum sig. Once again, I've incorporated my little personal logo. (The Three Tears in red and black, on the facing Warrior's shield).

I think this is my best work yet. Go easy. lol

By the way, the sig above me is awesome. :) 9/10 Only because 10 is hard for me to give, and the very dark, gothic imagery - just a personal quirk of mine is a distaste for gothic themes.

[Greyfang]

I'm back. With what is roughly my third attempt at a forum sig. Once again, I've incorporated my little personal logo. (The Three Tears in red and black, on the facing Warrior's shield).

I think this is my best work yet. Go easy. lol

By the way, the sig above me is awesome. :) 9/10 Only because 10 is hard for me to give, and the very dark, gothic imagery - just a personal quirk of mine is a distaste for gothic themes.

i like what you did with the tears on the shield, and the warrior holding it looks alright as well. i'm not fond of the background, it could use a little cleaning up, or it could just be too much going on for my taste, not sure. anyway, it looks like you put a lot of effort into it, i'll give it a 6.8/10.

[DarkCrusader]

9.0 Pretty sure I have rated yours many times......:cool:

[Soulwrecka]

9.0 Like how you made your own pics and stuff but theres no catchy phrase...

[Greyfang]

9.0 Pretty sure I have rated yours many times......:cool:

yes you have, and this latest one from you is sweet. i'm not usually a fan of rainbow-type colors, but that one's done with class, like tripping Death. :sly:

9/10

9.0 Like how you made your own pics and stuff but theres no catchy phrase...

little effort, no originality... 3/10

[Uncletouchme]

HI :D

Hey Dark that is pretty cool - kinda looks like a close up of the ork's hairs on an arm standing up-ish.... or back. Reminds me of the lion's armor in the french movie "Brotherhood...damn of something, can't remember the name now.

[DarkOblivion]

skip me, ive been looking, and a whole lot of you dont kno what makes a good sig, for eg: winterfreshes text fits the sig perfectly, and it is all very nicely done, worthy of a 9

[zaka]

5/10, cut and pasted images but nice flow of colors..

[Mash36]

Last edited by zaka; Today at 10:56 PM..


awsome.

[Parole]

0 :( Try again.

[zaka]

Last edited by zaka; Today at 10:56 PM..


awsome.

I changed my mind <_< that's what edits are for :D

[alexiogman]

you just wasted a few secs of your life reading this, and im not giving it back.


0/10 because I hate you. Give me back my time!

[DarkCrusader]

6.0 like the quote but no sig...:( for mash36
Thank you Uncletouchme and Greyfang and Soulwrecka just trying to make a decent sig forever ...........:cool:
7.9 for alexiogman nice wessex sig but ive seen better sry bud

[Temet nosce]

6.0 like the quote but no sig...:( for mash36
Thank you Uncletouchme and Greyfang and Soulwrecka just trying to make a decent sig forever ...........:cool:
7.9 for alexiogman nice wessex sig but ive seen better sry bud

Drunk/10, that's just bad Dark man, but you asked me to rate it since I was wasted. Taken individually, the elements of the sig are excellent (besides the text), but not a bit of it fits together.

[Uncletouchme]

Hey ya guys, I'm getting as bad as Dark - trying another sig idea.

Hit me!

[Temet nosce]

Hey ya guys, I'm getting as bad as Dark - trying another sig idea.

Hit me!

91/0, I fucking like it man. It's actually even better done than your last sig. It fits perfectly (is it all one piece?), except for the text. You might try finding a what the fuck do you call it... Style? Font? Yeah, font of text that fits better.

[aidgonewrong]

good but your sig still feels a little dull 9/10

[Beliathon]

2... not really a sig at all.

[Torzonborz]

my newest sig. yes I know it this plain and clear but I like it in this manner :p
http://torzonborz.uw.hu/DF/duud.jpg

[Greyfang]

my newest sig. yes I know it this plain and clear but I like it in this manner :p
http://torzonborz.uw.hu/DF/duud.jpg

the graphic is great, the rest is kinda meh.

5/10

[Whacko]

Great concept of the wolf, my only thing is the font in the lower left, it's difficult to see. but then again I've been having video issues.

Awesome overall.

8.7/10

[Uncletouchme]

Great concept of the wolf, my only thing is the font in the lower left, it's difficult to see. but then again I've been having video issues.

Awesome overall.

8.7/10

8/10 it's been changed a bit since I last saw it.

I love the addition :D

[Mosiah]

8/10

Love the cold misty early morning feel.

The ambusher in the tree stands out too much. The mist seems to evaperate between him and who ever is looking in his direction, mainly us who are rating your sig.

[Uncletouchme]

8/10

Love the cold misty early morning feel.

The ambusher in the tree stands out too much. The mist seems to evaperate between him and who ever is looking in his direction, mainly us who are rating your sig.

I adjusted the blend mode luminosity a tad, seems to blend in more now. He did stand out a bit but was not trying to make him to ninja like that he wouldn't be seen at all blending in too much with the tree.

I think this is a better blend without loosing him :ohno:

[Mosiah]

I adjusted the blend mode a tad, seems to blend in more now. He did stand out a bit but was not trying to make him to ninja like that he wouldn't be seen at all blending in too much with the tree.

I think this is a better blend without loosing him :ohno:

Bammmm, that did it. 10/10!

[Moridinn]

its not exactly one of the best lollercats around, but it still made me chuckle
6/10

[Wulf]

6/10, it's okay.

[Freyr]

A very solid sig, I'd like to see the text maybe a smidge bigger. 8/10

[cugine]

8/10. I'm not really sure what that is.

[Alphonse]

WOW 10/10 lol who is that? XD

But from a sig rating perspective i'd give it an 8/10 :D

[Bonney Goatbeard]

8/10

Nice details.

[DarkCrusader]

7.8 That is much different from the other drunken beggar clan sigs:cool:

[vlix]

8/10 I like the green, very orkish :D

[Whacko]

7.5
Gotta give ya props for the Font.

I've decided to go a different direction with the sig...

[Greyfang]

7.5
Gotta give ya props for the Font.

I've decided to go a different direction with the sig...

while it seems like a few different genres just kinda jumbled together, it still works in an odd way. ::shrug::

7.8/10

[Beliathon]

I think this is a better blend without loosing him :ohno:
I just caught up with the thread and felt I should mention I didn't even notice the jumping guy until it was mentioned... so maybe it does blend in too well now. >_<
(or it could just be me.. I just woke up..)

Also, someone please rate my fine MSpaint masterpiece. :p

[evadeszs]

5 points for coolness
3.5 points for that guys face lol all in all good sig

[Uncletouchme]

5 points for coolness
3.5 points for that guys face lol all in all good sig

6/10 not bad, but the winged image on the side needs to be cleaned up - way to blurry. Maybe squished too much? The black armored one looks kinda slapped on - no blending into background. I Like the font and swords.

[Sypher]

6/10 not bad, but the winged image on the side needs to be cleaned up - way to blurry. Maybe squished too much? The black armored one looks kinda slapped on - no blending into background. Like the font and swords.

7/10
It's just meh to me...nothing special.

[Mandriane]

5/10

not my type of sig tbh

[Praedo]

8/10

[Megumi]

8/10

6/10 kinda boring but I like the "cloth" look.

...Also, am I the only one who hates the cliché "fierce wolf-man" Mahirim sigs?

[Mandriane]

...Also, am I the only one who hates the cliché "fierce wolf-man" Mahirim sigs?

ya

[Freyr]

6/10 kinda boring but I like the "cloth" look.

...Also, am I the only one who hates the cliché "fierce wolf-man" Mahirim sigs?

I'm with ya, don't like em at all. I give you a 8/10 - love how colorful it is :D

[coxtrot]

3/10

You gotta get artistic :D

[Scholar]

Background looks strange, flames look very out of place, and the dwarf(?) is very frozen looking.

3.5/10
Edit:
Meh, I'll give u a 5.

[Dorkfail]

I give you a 0 because it looks like shit

[Scholar]

-10/10 :cool:

[Greyfang]

-10/10 :cool:

very polished. the Mahirim is a little cartoony for my taste (but i've made one or two of those myself), and it might benefit from a border, but overall it's well done.

8.75/10

[kowabunga]

very polished. the Mahirim is a little cartoony for my taste (but i've made one or two of those myself), and it might benefit from a border, but overall it's well done.

8.75/10

thats actually really good , i like it. 9/10

[Whacko]

Ummm.....well let's see
5/10 sorry but it's just Meh

I reverted back to my old one because my new ones sucked (not saying this one is good but it's better than my others)

[Ashfield212]

9/10

I always like to see something "different" and stylish!

[GunslingerV]

6.75/10, the blend of colors is a bit conflicting, and theres a visible black box right next to the tag (middle-top area of the sig)

[drakthule]

9/10 nice art

[skowyt]

v. nice, 8/10

http://img292.imageshack.us/img292/7968/rysujjjnek1xz6.jpg

[Skribbles]

10/10
the . is very profound

[Dorkfail]

9/10

I always like to see something "different" and stylish!

thank you

[Nehemia]

Seriously, what the hell is that? 6/10.

[Bahatouridhs]

5/10

[bas]

9/10, nice style but no border.