Rate The Sig Above You Thread!

[Insomniak]

8/10 Nice muted colours. The text in the background looks great with that chap superimposed on the right. Minus half a point for him looking squished though :)

11/10 because zombies are cool and Dimfall is teh SHIAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

anyways, I finally managed to add some color to my sig using my desktop background, i think it looks a lot better

[Nehemia]

9/10.
Dude, it looks a lot better, but I still see no border!

[Insomniak]

9/10.
Dude, it looks a lot better, but I still see no border!

6/10, no idea what it says, I don't like anime, and the guys face is squished...and I slapped on a border

[Hijiroku]

5/10 did he drop his contact?
well ii give u 5/10 dont like the new sig as much and ashlander looks like your not liked much on rate the sig thread

[Insomniak]

well ii give u 5/10 dont like the new sig as much and ashlander looks like your not liked much on rate the sig thread


i give that a 5/10 but invert it and
http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x181/insomniak0/New.jpg
voila! i give that an 8/10

[Wolfe Bennett]

8/10

[Khamul]

8/10 very cool

[Wolfe Bennett]

its cool 7/10

[Hijiroku]

i give that a 5/10 but invert it and
http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x181/insomniak0/New.jpg
voila! i give that an 8/10

soz dont use photoshop,and you like the invert stuff i dont really care for inverting stuff unless it has good outcome. Umm dont no the sig so u get 3/10

http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh157/Hijiroku/WOLFE.png

and wolfes pic inverted :D

[daan16]

i give that a 5/10 but invert it and
http://i186.photobucket.com/albums/x181/insomniak0/New.jpg
voila! i give that an 8/10

I agree this 1 is alot better then the one you having atm hijiroku. Yours is 6/10 with the red design its like a 7/10 / 8/10

[Spartan791]

yeah Hijiroku the red one is better

anyway daan 7/10

[Lorthral]

5/10

[gurinthedark]

5/10

Reasons?

Its not that bad.

For you,

7/10 but i'd give an 8 if the ork looked a little.. well.. Civilized.

[Zeonx]

10/10 great work.

[Spartan791]

9/10 looks cool

[Wolfe Bennett]

8/10 Because the duchy is awsome.

[gurinthedark]

8/10 Because the duchy is awsome.

Yeah right! Lol. Joke.

Already rated your sig.

[Insomniak]

soz dont use photoshop,and you like the invert stuff i dont really care for inverting stuff unless it has good outcome.

If the headache effect was what you were going for, then keep it, but the inverted version:

Looks bloody and works with the assassin part
Is easier on the eyes
Is much more readable

And inverting a sig can make it look much better or make it look like complete shit and the best part is...
It can be done in MSpaint, GIMP or just about any image-editing program


Anyways, I give Gurin's sig an 8/10. Nice implementation of the Warhammer Black KNight

[Lorthral]

Kinda blurry and plain. 7/10

My reasons for Slash's rating was the common Duchy format and the abundance of red.

[Hijiroku]

9/10 for cool sig and mean orc and were in same clan :)

[gurinthedark]

9/10 for cool sig and mean orc and were in same clan :)

Ok.....

Since we know you weren't the one to do that i can't give you more than a 7/10.

10/10 for the real artists work

[Hijiroku]

Ok.....

I love your text man. Its pwnage.

thnx 6/10

[gurinthedark]

thnx 6/10

Read my edit. Made a mistake, you need to chill.

[Hijiroku]

umm i dont no were you get that i didnt do this
and also your post wasnt edited when i read it so u need 2 chill

[gurinthedark]

If the headache effect was what you were going for, then keep it, but the inverted version:

Looks bloody and works with the assassin part
Is easier on the eyes
Is much more readable

And inverting a sig can make it look much better or make it look like complete shit and the best part is...
It can be done in MSpaint, GIMP or just about any image-editing program


Anyways, I give Gurin's sig an 8/10. Nice implementation of the Warhammer Black KNight

Here it is. Most people obviously like my sig.

Your other sig looked like shit.

[Hijiroku]

thnx 7.5 stupid post this was supposed 2 be a edit not a new post

[gurinthedark]

thnx 7.5

????

Did you even read what i wrote?

[Hijiroku]

yea sumptin like 10/10 soz but im not into just slapping pics on sumtin im more of the abstract person made from scratch.And i dont give a fuck if u think my other sig looked like shit and your sig looks like shit also.I could just give you a 4 which would be my real rating for your sig.

[gurinthedark]

yea sumptin like 10/10 soz but im not into just slapping pics on sumtin im more of the abstract person made from scratch

I see..

[Zeeded]

does this go to negatives?

[gurinthedark]

No, im afraid i can't give you more than a 0/10.

[Zokten]

2/10

Very basic, looks like bunch of text and pics thrown together. No border, no blending, etc.

But the text choice seems pretty good at least.

[Ashlander]

8/10 The dragon head on the right makes it look off, but you put an overlay or something on it like the other side it'd be much better. Looks great other then that though.

[ThreatLetterBox]

9/10 get rid of the cliche lighting effects. The border is a bit messed up.
Hiji and Guri learn to shut the fuck up, rate, and move on.

[Spartan791]

I don't want to be bad but 5/10

[ThreatLetterBox]

I don't want to be bad but 5/10

I'm sure you arrived at that conclusion from a technical standpoint and not an aesthetic one. I really don't care if you don't like the color or the font if you can't even criticize it. 8/10 for yours. I love the colors and all, but a bit of brushing would be a nice add. I'm editing mine some. It came out just a bit wrong.

[Spartan791]

yep that's better m8
7.5/10 looks nice

[Zeeded]

7/10

[ThreatLetterBox]

7/10

Get a new signature!

[Zeeded]

What?

[ThreatLetterBox]

What?

Your signature is stretched out and the render develops into complete black for no reason. It's unnecessarily large and rather plain. There's a random strip of complete white at the end on purpose or not that seems out of place. The font is obnoxious. 3/10

Better?...

[Zeeded]

Your signature is stretched out and the render develops into complete black for no reason. It's unnecessarily large and rather plain. There's a random strip of complete white at the end on purpose or not that seems out of place. The font is obnoxious. 3/10

Better?...

Yes, ill get to work. But the part about the font is Bullshit

[Ashlander]

I like the render, who cares if your sig is DF related or not? The rest is plain though and i dont like the text. I dont see the white bar the guy mentioned though.

6/10

[Skribbles]

7/10
The Good:
nice textures, easy to read words
The Bad:
the pic is kinda hard to make out... looks like its too detailed to be that small
The Ugly
im not sure if u were going for this but the border has traces of the texture on it as well as the main pic on the bottom... left side of the border


overall tho i do like the sig

[Rotten_Pieces]

10/10


<3

[ThreatLetterBox]

Haha. 9/10.

[Ashlander]

7/10
The Good:
nice textures, easy to read words
The Bad:
the pic is kinda hard to make out... looks like its too detailed to be that small
The Ugly
im not sure if u were going for this but the border has traces of the texture on it as well as the main pic on the bottom... left side of the border


overall tho i do like the sig
The border is an overlay, its supposed to be like that.

8/10 Text is a little hard to read but still looks great.

[gurinthedark]

Gotta fix the lighting. Its kind of dark under.

7/10

[ThreatLetterBox]

Four pictures thrown on top of each other with some decent text, a horrible quote, and an over-emphasized name. 4/10

[Lorthral]

Four pictures thrown on top of each other with some decent text, a horrible quote, and an over-emphasized name. 4/10

Awesome but I would suggest making the text a bit bigger.

[Wolfe Bennett]

Awesome but I would suggest making the text a bit bigger.

even though i have rated yours before i looked at it closer now and i give it a 8.5/10 its cool looking, and the colors blend well, ect

[ThreatLetterBox]

The render is amazingly well done. Not the cutting but the art. The text is nice and so is the background. I don't care for the black border style or how Duchy of Wessex and Realm of Kirdain do that stupid obnoxious branding in the bottom of all their signatures. 9/10

[Wolfe Bennett]

The render is amazingly well done. Not the cutting but the art. The text is nice and so is the background. I don't care for the black border style or how Duchy of Wessex and Realm of Kirdain do that stupid obnoxious branding in the bottom of all their signatures. 9/10
I like it 9/10 but the bottem text is hard to read. ohh and i like our little brand at the corner ^^

[ThreatLetterBox]

I like it 9/10 but the bottem text is hard to read. ohh and i like our little brand at the corner ^^

Yeah I decreased the size and I don't want to make the text much bigger. It's okay, I just don't like how it's so plain and poorly done, sometimes obnoxious. =/
I'll back away now and let the ratings continue. >.>

[Rotten_Pieces]

0/10

banned.

[Lorthral]

0/10

banned.

...

No rating.

[Komako]

1/10

Sucks.

[Lorthral]

Lol that was a good one.

9.5/10

[Zeeded]

2/10

[gurinthedark]

7/10

You finally changed it!

[Lorthral]

2/10

Reasons? Yours sucks by the way.

For gurin, already rated.

[Surly]

2/10

[Ashlander]

2/10 Im not an ass man

[Surly]

0/10. You're an ass, man.

[Pwned Sideways]

7/10. Why smurfs?

Pwned Sideways.

[Ashlander]

7/10 Its ok, dont like the text so much.

[Kaorn]

8/10

Mahirim should have been sideways, but nice otherwise.

[Zokten]

8/10

Mahirim should have been sideways, but nice otherwise.

Simple I like, but looks like text thrown on a background.

4/10

[Ashlander]

You did the wrong person =P

7/10 the letters/numbers are too jumbled together, should look more like a grid then just jumbled up

[Hijiroku]

9/10 i like the lighting more than your previous sig. :D good job :D

[Spartan791]

7/10 the letters are kinda hard to read and the edges don't look nice

[Helgeran]

A duchy sig with something that resembles an actual character! Nice colors, nice pic find. It's awesome.

[Ashlander]

6/10 kinda boring

[Spartan791]

I like the changes you have made
8/10

[Zeeded]

Reasons? Yours sucks by the way.

For gurin, already rated.

The reason is urs is poorly colored and ugly and u fucked alot up. just get a new one.


and the one above me gets a 7.65/10

i thinks theres a little to much text and the colors are funky, but i still like it

[Spartan791]

better than your previous one but you still need a better one
6/10

[Hijiroku]

agreed slash 7/10 way to much red and my borders are perfectly fine as forth you dont even have complete borders

[Lorthral]

2/10

Go fuck yourself.

[Ashlander]

8.5/10 Looks good but still dont like orcs =P

[Insomniak]

8.5/10 Looks good but still dont like orcs =P

MUCH easier on the old eyes. I now award you with your 8/10.

[Wolfe Bennett]

9/10 very good no real complaints

[Zeeded]

7/10 theres to much text on ur sig

[Ashlander]

4/10 Not really that good, just an image with a pattern and a black background.

[Hijiroku]

8

[FrostByte]

8

I do like the base design of your sigs...allthough you seem to always find a way to cock them up.
This time it´s the bright white border and yellow rays in the text.
6/10.

[Spartan791]

I do like the base design of your sigs...allthough you seem to always find a way to cock them up.
This time it´s the bright white border and yellow rays in the text.
6/10.

see hiji your borders I told you


for frost a 7.5/10

[Suitepee]

see hiji your borders I told you


for frost a 7.5/10

The writing of the Footman of the Ducal Garrison area is a bit blurred,other than that an ok sig.
7/10.

[Zeeded]

5/10

[OrMZeN]

5/10

Personally I don't like the harsh sharp edges of the blackness. I would prefer if you made all the black to Forumfall-gray instead.

Other than that, nice.
7/10

[Skribbles]

8/10
i like it... cant really say much about it but it does look nice... and i agree the skull would look ALOT better if it came outta the forum instead of black

[OrMZeN]

A quick work in photoshop; personally - I think it looks alot better.
Name's a bit hard to read though and the head is cropped unfortunally, but meh. Alot better still, imo.

http://img151.imageshack.us/img151/2263/zeededxs9.jpg

Rate Skribbles sig, not mine!

[Hrothga]

8/10
i like it... cant really say much about it but it does look nice... and i agree the skull would look ALOT better if it came outta the forum instead of black

I like your signature. Thou i don't now if it has been rated before this thread has over 170 pages.

8/10

[Hrothga]

9/10 very good no real complaints

Wolfe, i like your signature. Wonder why :rolleyes:

[Spartan791]

Wolfe, i like your signature. Wonder why :rolleyes:

Duchy ftw

100/10:D

ok let's get serious 8/10

[Zokten]

5/10

Border I think is horrible for the sig, almost no blending, the colors get my attention but not in a good way, the font choice is decent but just slapped on top of the sig.

[Ashlander]

Looks good but the right dragon head still bothers me =P

8/10

[Wolfe Bennett]

Looks good but the right dragon head still bothers me =P

8/10

nice new lighting 7.5/10

[Thredra Aranax]

Some reason its not there. :*(

[Spartan791]

the greatest sig I've ever seen
1000/10 :ninja::ninja:

[Lorthral]

Not the best sig I've ever seen.

Already rated it anyways.

[gurinthedark]

Not the best sig I've ever seen.

Already rated it anyways.

Neither is yours. Sorry, its alright but it doesn't stand out and is like any other orkish sig.

[Thredra Aranax]

there now its there.

[Zokten]

Neither is yours. Sorry, its alright but it doesn't stand out and is like any other orkish sig.

Lol, his sig has stood out compared to 98% of other's I've seen....like yours. Sorry thats how it is.

[Wolfe Bennett]

there now its there.

i like your sig 8.5/10 very interesting

and zokten 5/10 the dragons look too fake and it doesnt have a body i can see the end of the head and sorry to say but its kind of dull.

[Zokten]

3/10

Basic in a bad way, No border, poor font choice, and overall just looks slapped together.

[Ashlander]

10/10 Simple and complex at the same time, one color, but still looks awesome. Great job.

[Fluffington]

3/10

Basic in a bad way, No border, poor font choice, and overall just looks slapped together.

Sounds like someone got their feelings hurt, need a hug?

[Nehemia]

7/10

I can't think anyone with that bad sense of humor, I mean, who the fuck would attach a retarded quote to a stupid picture?

I would.

[daan16]

6/10

I liked your old one better. srry :)

[Fluffington]

7/10

I can't think anyone with that bad sense of humor, I mean, who the fuck would attach a retarded quote to a stupid picture?

I would.

You gave your own sig a bad rating? It`s an awesome sig, when attached to the catalyst that is my post count it becomes EPIC.

[Zeeded]

8/10

[Wolfe Bennett]

8/10 plain yet really cool at the same time

[daan16]

One of the better duchy of wessex sigs.

8/10

[Wolfe Bennett]

One of the better duchy of wessex sigs.

8/10

thank you and i give a 8.5/10 for yours its really cool

[daan16]

thank you and i give a 8.5/10 for yours its really cool

Ty. Not much to see on its just looking good. At the right of my picture you see the logo of the squad im leading.

[gurinthedark]

Cool sig. Nice use of colours. Should have your clan logo on it though.

8/10

[daan16]

Cool sig. Nice use of colours. Should have your clan logo on it though.

8/10

Clan logo doesn't really fit at it. Anyway yours 8.5/10

[Zokten]

Sounds like someone got their feelings hurt, need a hug?

Lol, nice assuming.

[daan16]

just a simple sig. So i would say chose one of the others you got.

5/10

[Zokten]

How is simple bad if I may ask?

But yours 7/10
Simple but a good kind of simple, but the border really messes it up in a bad way. I'd also maybe make text a little smaller.

[OrMZeN]

just a simple sig. So i would say chose one of the others you got.

5/10

I'd also like to state that at the first glance at your sig it looks like it says "Empire of Latency"... which would be an awesome clanname imo

[Zeeded]

6/10

[Ashlander]

6/10 Meh... looks ok, nothing special about it.

[Fluffington]

Lol, nice assuming.

Is my assuming impressive or are you talking about my assumption? Learn2english.

[Elxu]

Is my assuming impressive or are you talking about my assumption? Learn2english.

Cute dog with cute hat eating cute pie! 7.5/10

[Zokten]

Is my assuming impressive or are you talking about my assumption? Learn2english.

/golfclap

Gratz your a grammar nazi want a cookie?

Sorry my typing was both on lack of sleep.

[Nehemia]

8,5/10.

Its good looking, but the problem is that the character is too blended into the background, if there is one, but at least there seems to be one.

[FrostByte]

I still think that it´s too pastel colored and looks gay, but - except for slight squishines of character - it´s well made so... 8/10.

[daan16]

Nice usage of colors and a good picture used at it.

9/10

[Spartan791]

your new sig is good looking daan
8.5/10

[Wolfe Bennett]

sup slash 1000000000000/10 for your sig.

[gurinthedark]

sup slash 1000000000000/10 for your sig.

0/100000000000000000

for that comment.

[alfaroverall]

7/10. It's kind of clunky, the picture isn't that great, the background is plagued by the text, and the text isn't that great.

[Fluffington]

/golfclap

Gratz your a grammar nazi want a cookie?

Sorry my typing was both on lack of sleep.

The nazis turned Germany into a super power when they were gangbanged by the allies in WW1, if I can do the same here you will owe me more then a golf clap.

[Zokten]

The nazis turned Germany into a super power when they were gangbanged by the allies in WW1, if I can do the same here you will owe me more then a golf clap.

Perhaps I will.....

[OrMZeN]

Perhaps I will.....

Perhaps you won't...

8/10 for an awesome blended in character in the sig.

Doesn't really fit to the theme of DF though, but the sig itself is pretty neat.

[Spartan791]

0/100000000000000000

for that comment.

-10000000000000000000/1000000000000000000

for that comment



Ormzen 9/10

[Giran]

9/10

lets see if mine shows up....first time ever trying to make a sig

[Fluffington]

The quality is a little wierd, needs more umbrellas and less blur.

[Spartan791]

The Best sig ever 10/10 :D:D

[Suitepee]

The quality is a little wierd, needs more umbrellas and less blur.

5 muffins out of blueberry.

[Fluffington]

5 muffins out of blueberry.

Your blueberry standards are too high, I suggest a more accepting apple or peach system.

[Wolfe Bennett]

9.5/10 because the muffin is upside down.

[Apex Vertigo]

9.5/10 because the muffin is upside down.

8.5/10 sig

0/10 quote

[Lorthral]

8.5/10 sig

0/10 quote

7.5/10

Kinda hard to see the picture unless you change your focus.

[Suitepee]

7.5/10

Kinda hard to see the picture unless you change your focus.

Vicious looking orc,7/10.
Would have been 9/10 if it was Mahirim. :D

[Zeeded]

sig 3/10

1st qoute 7/10

2nd qoute 9/10

[alfaroverall]

7.5/10 I suppose...it's not bad by any means, it's just...nothing special.

[Suitepee]

sig 3/10

1st qoute 7/10

2nd qoute 9/10

Half-assed Gears of War icon sig,5/10. More background intensity needed.

Alfar: 8/10. Nice and clear mostly.

[Spartan791]

7/10 good

[Hijiroku]

I do like the base design of your sigs...allthough you seem to always find a way to cock them up.
This time it´s the bright white border and yellow rays in the text.
6/10.

do you mean fuck them up ???? actually i only used the inverted one because evryone liked it more than the other one dont really like it much though i have a diffrent signature but file size is to big

[Ulla_jensen]

5/10, to much going on, pretty violent

[gurinthedark]

do you mean fuck them up ???? actually i only used the inverted one because evryone liked it more than the other one dont really like it much though i have a diffrent signature but file size is to big

I can't even read it now. Make it a little calmer,,

[Hijiroku]

5/10, to much going on, pretty violent

Just a thought how is it voilent.There is nothing but text and abstact art.

All ready rated yours gurin so person above gurin gets a 2/5 cant read the text use a diffrent font,doesn't look good either.It also looks pixilated like you set the resolution at 50%

and dont even comment about me putting the score as a 2/5 jsut for you stupid people it would be 4/10

[Suitepee]

Just a thought how is it voilent.There is nothing but text and abstact art.

All ready rated yours gurin so person above gurin gets a 3/5 cant read the text use a diffrent font,doesn't look good either.It also looks pixilated like you set the resolution at 50%

4/10. Looks pretty ugly and blurred imo.

[daan16]

Not really what i like though its not that bad i guess .

6.5/10

Ps: hijiroku the color you used a while ago for that sig were better. The bleu or the red one.

[Lorthral]

Sucks. Just like your pitiful clan.

0/10

[daan16]

Sucks. Just like your pitiful clan.

0/10

LoL and your happy with hijiroku that make the clan sigs. The sigs he make are just to ugly to use. Anyway i'm not gonna rate your sig 0/10 because your clan sucks.

If this is one of hijiroku made sigs then its the only one that looks good of the ones that he created.

7/10

[Lorthral]

LoL and your happy with hijiroku that make the clan sigs. The sigs he make are just to ugly to use. Anyway i'm not gonna rate your sig 0/10 because your clan sucks.

If this is one of hijiroku made sigs then its the only one that looks good of the ones that he created.

7/10

Who says we use those? We have 3 graphic designers.

[Hijiroku]

LoL and your happy with hijiroku that make the clan sigs. The sigs he make are just to ugly to use. Anyway i'm not gonna rate your sig 0/10 because your clan sucks.

If this is one of hijiroku made sigs then its the only one that looks good of the ones that he created.

7/10

I just put them up there I care less if they use it or not since sar'gath or the other person can just make a sig plus i'm more abstract and yes i made the sig and i suppose your some new troll 08'er? ill admit im an 08'er but im not a troll looks like all you can do is find pictures on google and put text on it becuse thats the only way you can make any sigs

[daan16]

I just put them up there I care less if they use it or not since sar'gath or the other person can just make a sig plus i'm more abstract and yes i made the sig and i suppose your some new troll 08'er? ill admit im an 08'er but im not a troll looks like all you can do is find pictures on google and put text on it becuse thats the only way you can make any sigs

Haha sure. And no i'm from 2007. And i don't make my own sigs cause i admit that i'm bad in it. You should admit that too.

[f3lony]

7

[Nehemia]

Greasy WoW players ala South Park... 6/10.
You could have at least had some trouble by adding text - borders, gosh.
And Daan,Hirojiku, don't fight in this thread, geez. Daan's in EoL, well, what can I say. Hirojiku, if I remember correctly created the most stereotypical assassin clan of 12 year olds?
So... Just quit it.

[daan16]

Greasy WoW players ala South Park... 6/10.
You could have at least had some trouble by adding text - borders, gosh.
And Daan,Hirojiku, don't fight in this thread, geez. Daan's in EoL, well, what can I say. Hirojiku, if I remember correctly created the most stereotypical assassin clan of 12 year olds?
So... Just quit it.

Hmmm.. Whats wrong with EoL?

[Zokten]

6/10
daan, your sig would be a lot better if it didn't have that horrible border. You should ask the person who did it to re-do the border.

And, make the text a little smaller.

[Nehemia]

Hmmm.. Whats wrong with EoL?

8.5/10 to Zokten.

And there's nothing wrong with EoL, expect you've made its reputation little.. Considerable. By your polls.
Now don't post here without a rating signature, darn it.

[Skribbles]

9/10
really like it... its clean, has style and its not the same layout as 99% of the sigs

[Suitepee]

9/10
really like it... its clean, has style and its not the same layout as 99% of the sigs

Your old sig was better. :D

[daan16]

8.5/10 to Zokten.

And there's nothing wrong with EoL, expect you've made its reputation little.. Considerable. By your polls.
Now don't post here without a rating signature, darn it.

People just overreact about my polls. And i haven't made polls for 2 weeks now so....

Anyway 6.5/10 suitepee

[Apex Vertigo]

And there's nothing wrong with EoL, expect you've made its reputation little.. Considerable. By your polls.
Now don't post here without a rating signature, darn it.

Lol... So we have one member who makes silly polls and that determines the reputation for every member in our clan? Way to make yourself look like an ignorant jack ass.

10/10 daans sig for the awesome sig master.

[Lorthral]

Lol... So we have one member who makes silly polls and that determines the reputation for every member in our clan? What to make yourself look like an ignorant jack ass.

10/10 daans sig for the awesome sig master.


He came to our forums and told us that we would get crushed by EoL and that he'd have fun doing it. He's the ignorant jackass here, not Nehemia. I would suggest demoting him or kicking him from the clan because I have seen him do this to many other clans besides mine.

He's giving you enemies you do not want.

EDIT: 7/10

[Apex Vertigo]

He came to our forums and told us that we would get crushed by EoL and that he'd have fun doing it. He's the ignorant jackass here, not Nehemia. I would suggest demoting him or kicking him from the clan because I have seen him do this to many other clans besides mine.

He's giving you enemies you do not want.

EDIT: 7/10

I find it fairly ignorant to judge a clan soley based on the posting record of one member.

7/10.

[OrMZeN]

Rate My Siiiiiig!!!!

[Nehemia]

Rate My Siiiiiig!!!!

The bar just closed, eh, dear Ormz?

8/10.

[Ash'Luskr]

Alright technically we are not at war with anybody as of right now. and nehemia i like the layout of your signature different, though imo the letters should be straight and not falling off and up.
9/10 for an almost flawless signature.

[Suitepee]

Alright technically we are not at war with anybody as of right now. and nehemia i like the layout of your signature different, though imo the letters should be straight and not falling off and up.
9/10 for an almost flawless signature.

8/10.

[Lorthral]

Someone deleted my posts. :bang:

8/10

[daan16]

Same here. :bang:

7/10

[Lorthral]

Same here. :bang:

7/10

5/10

That's what your sig is without the clan.

[kilkan]

Someone deleted my posts. :bang:

8/10

if the mods are deleting your posts, maybe its a good time to shut your mouth and quit trolling.
7.5/10

[Lorthral]

if the mods are deleting your posts, maybe its a good time to shut your mouth and quit trolling.
7.5/10

Heh funny quotes. 8/10 for quotes. 0/10 for sig.

[Carnivo]

New sig. I like it cause its different, but I wanna see what you guys think too.

7/10

[Fluffington]

New sig. I like it cause its different, but I wanna see what you guys think too.

7/10

Anarchy is stupid.

[Apex Vertigo]

Anarchy is stupid.

5/10. Suppose to be a funny sig but personally, I just don't find it too funny. Maybe because I don't like dogs or cup cakes.

EDIT: Also... it says "I haz muffin", but to me it looks much like a cupcake. Is that part of the joke?

[Carnivo]

9/10 - Very nice
Anarchy is stupid.
Thanks for rating my signature.

[Fluffington]

9/10 - Very nice

Thanks for rating my signature.

Not every rating has to be in a "out of 10" system, I though you anarchist kids would be all over this sort of pointless deviation of the rules.

[Carnivo]

Not every rating has to be in a "out of 10" system, I though you anarchist kids would be all over this sort of pointless deviation of the rules.
I'm not an anarchist.

[Fluffington]

5/10. Suppose to be a funny sig but personally, I just don't find it too funny. Maybe because I don't like dogs or cup cakes.

EDIT: Also... it says "I haz muffin", but to me it looks much like a cupcake. Is that part of the joke?

It`s a juxtaposition, my signature is nonsensical and childish but my posts are often serious and harsh. Think of it like getting kicked in the teeth for being an idiot and then the same person giggles.

[Nehemia]

It`s a juxtaposition, my signature is nonsensical and childish but my posts are often serious and harsh. Think of it like getting kicked in the teeth for being an idiot and then the same person giggles.

Your work reflects of artists personality, but when talking seriously, I made that for you as a joke, and well.. It seems to get better ratings than my serious ones, oh the irony.
Want a border to it?

[Spartan791]

This thread is about rating not flaming!!!!!!!!
8/10

[Blackie_Chan]

This thread is about rating not flaming!!!!!!!!
8/10
I like the left half of the sig, but I don't really see what it is transitioning to on the right, I think some work could be done to make it more clear so everything you are trying to express is more visible.

7.5/10

[Razli]

10/10...Black Jesus is amazing.

[Spartan791]

hmmm 6/10 I don't like groovy dogs

[Carnivo]

7/10 It's sort of hard to tell what that thing is on the right. I'd guess a Phoenix, but its still hard to tell.

[Mippoose]

7/10

Just fine.

Rate this:

http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b75/Mippoose/dietryingcopy.jpg

[Zokten]

2/10

[Mippoose]

1/10

Sig matches your graybush, graybush.

[Zokten]

1/10

Sig matches your graybush, graybush.

Little hurt over the rating it seems.

[III [C*D]]

Little hurt over the rating it seems.

1/10 - No originality. Use the word "sig" in his "sig."

L2sig.

[Carnivo]

7/10 to Zokten. I think it would look better with some color, but we all have our preferences.

[Zokten]

7/10 to Zokten. I think it would look better with some color, but we all have our preferences.

I have a blue color version also. But I just like the color gray more, and like it more with the render.

6/10

I like it for the most part, just seems overly plain.

[Spartan791]

7/10

[Rovo]

8/10
nice colors, but i really cant make out the background, is it suppose to make sense? All i can see is a guy with a mustache swinging a sword who looks like a pirate.

[Suitepee]

8/10
nice colors, but i really cant make out the background, is it suppose to make sense? All i can see is a guy with a mustache swinging a sword who looks like a pirate.

10/10. :D

[Thee Prince]

My sig is cool

[Nehemia]

In my opinion, thats no signature, its just bad illustration of Zidane of Tantaulus and on top of that, its 100x100 image, you just raped the character.

2/10.

[Carnivo]

9/10 - very original, and a very cool design.

[shadowww]

8/10 i like ur "style" :)

[alfaroverall]

To Carnivo since shadowww has no sig:
On an objective level it's good. I can't critique it in that sense. I just don't like the stylistic aspect of it; it's a matter of taste. So objectively I'll give this an 8/10, but for a personal response I'd say 5/10. Not your fault though, we just have conflicting tastes.

[shadowww]

i have sig lol, some weird bug o0

btw. yours is.. ordinary, seen sth. similar before :P 7/10

[Lorthral]

i have sig lol, some weird bug o0

btw. yours is.. ordinary, seen sth. similar before :P 7/10

Reminds me of LotR. 7/10

[Ash'Luskr]

THE ORK PWNS a like the sceme of it all it flows well.
9/10 ( if i give you a ten can i be a warlord :D lol j/k...or am I?)

[AOD_Flamefleir]

3/10

it has a 'cluttered' look

[Lorthral]

3/10

it has a 'cluttered' look

Your sig has "nowhere near enough clutter." Can't even call it a sig!

0/10

[AOD_Flamefleir]

3/10

overdone

[Ungraylessness]

I have a new sig better than the old one?

As for AOD 10/10 pats on the back all around

[Lorthral]

I have a new sig better than the old one?

As for AOD 10/10 pats on the back all around

10/10 :D

[alfaroverall]

6/10...I don't get it.

[Lorthral]

6/10...I don't get it.

8/10 I get it...

[Nehemia]

8/10, the boooordeeer. Darn it.

[Lorthral]

8/10, the boooordeeer. Darn it.


9.5/10...It's awesome.

[Ungraylessness]

9.5/10...It's awesome.

10/10

Btw when did DOTSS monopolize the art forum?

[Lorthral]

10/10

Btw when did DOTSS monopolize the art forum?

Who knows? Ask Zok, he's the Art mod.

[gurinthedark]

Who knows? Ask Zok, he's the Art mod.

The ork in this looks much more civilised than you. But still, its Lorthral so i give you a..

8/100.

[Zokten]

The ork in this looks much more civilised than you. But still, its Lorthral so i give you a..

8/100.

3.5/10

The render should be in the background not the foreground.

The logo should just be removed or made smaller to fit into the black border after the render if moved to the background.

The text effects "Gurikid" just doesn't seem to work well with the sig.

The font for "Realm of Kirdain" is a bad choice and the effect makes it a little hard to read.

[Ungraylessness]

I made a new sig, very artsey someone non biased (sg) rate it for me

Gurin, there is a bar / meter thing in your sig that distracts me from your armored guy and black boarder

8/10 clearly you've had it for a while

[Ungraylessness]

Zok, i don't like your guy's lazer eye

10/10

[Rotten_Pieces]

4/10 grey and dull.

[Zokten]

Rotten

9/10 So funny and simple that I can't help but like it.

[El Chupacabra]

8/10

Color scheme reminds me of my own sig.

[Blackie_Chan]

8/10

Color scheme reminds me of my own sig.
Ugly like a Chupa, but too much red 7.5/10

[Rotten_Pieces]

9/10 for water break dancing

[Blackie_Chan]

9/10 for water break dancing
i give you a 9.5/10 for the heavenly beer. You should make the stars stand out a bit more or give a halo gloss to the beer to make the heavenly part more appearant.

Oh and its not Guiness so that marked you down some too.

[Suitepee]

i give you a 9.5/10 for the heavenly beer. You should make the stars stand out a bit more or give a halo gloss to the beer to make the heavenly part more appearant.

Oh and its not Guiness so that marked you down some too.

10/10. :D
I'd love to see that on the religious channels.

[anarcho]

i made this one

[Damukag]

7/10

Really simple, uncluttered, and somewhat badass.

[Blackauron]

eh 6/10, didn't really strike me as anything special

[Zokten]

3/10

The render just looks...well bad cause of the effect on it. Also don't like having the larger render of his face right behind him, should just remove it all together. Should make the font smaller so it doesn't hump the render as much. Also think the font choice is bad for all the text.

[Lorthral]

3/10

The render just looks...well bad cause of the effect on it. Also don't like having the larger render of his face right behind him, should just remove it all together. Should make the font smaller so it doesn't hump the render as much. Also think the font choice is bad for all the text.

6/10 Not your best.

[AOD_Flamefleir]

8/10

not too much not too bad

[Zeeded]

4/10

[Rosscifer]

6.5/10 Should put the skull on some kind of background.

[Rotten_Pieces]

6/10

[GFH_Spike]

6/10 - Bad positioning of the text, poor use of space. Other than that, nice.

[Zeeded]

7/10 funny but kinda crappy.

[ThreatLetterBox]

I really wish you would have used more of the black up.

[GFH_Spike]

I really wish you would have used more of the black up.

8/10 - Simple design, works fine.

http://img186.imageshack.us/img186/3928/zebracake2oq3.gif

How does that compare to my current signature? :)

[ThreatLetterBox]

8/10 - Simple design, works fine.

http://img186.imageshack.us/img186/3928/zebracake2oq3.gif

How does that compare to my current signature? :)

I think you should leave it the way it is. I can improve it if you want. With the way Hitler's head is nearly cut off an outline effect won't work.

[Zeeded]

5/10

[ThreatLetterBox]

5/10

I have a rather large dislike of people who rate a signature yet can't bother with an explanation, criticism, or advice of any kind.

5/10 on professional standing, 8.5/10 for if it was made in Gimp like I believe it was.