Shemale vs Fat Chick (Part 2 of my social experiment)

[Eyrothath]

Welcome to part 2 of this interesting social experiment, I am starting to question my sexuality at this point, I went to so my porn sites to get pictures of shemales for this experiment..

Again, there is no nudity.. Same rules apply, you must pick either A. or B. I used a different shemale/transexual this time. I also have her up against a real female instead of the mangina. So here it is.

http://i482.photobucket.com/albums/rr189/Jonnyboy22/Socialexperimentpart2.jpg

[generic_user]

Once again I am spared the choice.

[Eyrothath]

Once again I am spared the choice.

I do not think you understand the idea behind my thread. I currently have proof that a straight male would have sex with a transvestite, and it would not make them gay. It is because the transvestite was attractive and feminine. Don't get me wrong, a average straight guy would throw them out of a window if a hot woman had a dick (most likely.) But given the choice of a attractive male to female tranny and a very un-attractive female, they will pick the tranny..

[generic_user]

I do not think you understand the idea behind my thread. I currently have proof that a straight male would have sex with a transvestite, and it would not make them gay. It is because the transvestite was attractive and feminine. Don't get me wrong, a average straight guy would throw them out of a window if a hot woman had a dick (most likely.) But given the choice of a attractive male to female tranny and a very un-attractive female, they will pick the tranny..

How does that have anything to do with what I said?

[Forgin]

You have to be clearer in your question because there is a big difference in finding someone attractive and being willing to fuck them.

I can honestly say I find the shemale hot (I'm sexually attracted to him/her)
but when it comes to having sex with him, I think I would rather just close my eyes and fuck the fat chick.

[Eyrothath]

You have to be clearer in your question because there is a big difference in finding someone attractive and being willing to fuck them.

I can honestly say I find the shemale hot (I'm sexually attracted to him/her)
but when it comes to having sex with him, I think I would rather just close my eyes and fuck the fat chick.

I don't understand this, if you more sexually attractive to the shemale, and find them more hot than the fat chick, why would you pick the fat one to have sex with?

I do not think it has anything to do with being straight or gay, if you are attractive to femininity, then you are straight, if you are attractive to masculinity, then I think that would make you gay, regardless the gender.

[Forgin]

I don't understand this, if you more sexually attractive to the shemale, and find them more hot than the fat chick, why would you pick the fat one to have sex with?

Cus she has a vagina to fuck, and no penis that would get in the way or balls slapping against mine.

[Oo_]

I feel like a lab rat

[Forgin]

I feel like a lab rat

That fat chick would eat you.

[Rahavin]

I don't understand this, if you more sexually attractive to the shemale, and find them more hot than the fat chick, why would you pick the fat one to have sex with?

I do not think it has anything to do with being straight or gay, if you are attractive to femininity, then you are straight, if you are attractive to masculinity, then I think that would make you gay, regardless the gender.

He's a bit gun shy.

Make the polls public by the way, it's funnier. (Even though it will affect your outcome of your psych experiment?)

[alfaroverall]

It's pretty much gonna be the same thing all the way through for pretty much everybody. We'd rather do foreplay and all that entails (minus any genital contact) with the shemale and then close our eyes and suffer through intercourse with the fat chick.

[Eyrothath]

Cus she has a vagina to fuck, and no penis that would get in the way or balls slapping against mine.

If you ever watched gay porn or transexual porn, the penis' are never, ever able to slap against the person who is giving it cause it does not reach, unless you have a huge penis (which transexuals do not have.) The hormones make your penis smaller.

[mookee]

I don't think your posts are supposed to conduct any social experiments, you are simply trying to justify your attraction to chicks with dicks.

[LaytoRest]

Yet, again, with some minor changes:

I say B with the lamp lightbulb busted, the lights out, doggystyle, a pillow behind "her" head, and anal. (Being there's no vagina to stick the dong into, anal is the way. Unless you can get through a man(woman?) blowing you, anal only makes you feel like you're in prison asserting yourself and becoming the rapist.)

[Forgin]

If you ever watched gay porn or transexual porn, the penis' are never, ever able to slap against the person who is giving it cause it does not reach, unless you have a huge penis (which transexuals do not have.) The hormones make your penis smaller.

Well I have never watched gay/transsexual porn. Considering this though, I think I would just fuck the shemale from behind while holding her titties and just keep my tights focused on her tits or ass.

[alexiogman]

uhhh.. wow.:bang: there should be a choice 3: "no thanks, I'll stick with nerdrage and masturbation"

[Forgin]

uhhh.. wow.:bang: there should be a choice 3: "no thanks, I'll stick with nerdrage and masturbation"

I absolutely hate people who pick the "I'll go with C lol" option when they are given a choice between A and B.

[Scully]

They're retards unable to make hard choices.

[alexiogman]

I absolutely hate people who pick the "I'll go with C lol" option when they are given a choice between A and B.

Post op and penis replaced with a manufactured vagina, I'd go with shemale. Pre op... the choice is still between eating someone else's shit and your own... who gives a fuck who's shit it is? you'll still be puking afterward.

edit: there is ALWAYS a choice C even when it's not available.

[alexiogman]

Hell... while im at it, what if you wanna do both?

[Eyrothath]

Hell... while im at it, what if you wanna do both?

Explain.. Do you mean some kind of three-way?

[LaytoRest]

edit: there is ALWAYS a choice C even when it's not available.

Suicide!?
=D

[Rahavin]

Hell... while im at it, what if you wanna do both?

A new development, me and a tranny double teaming a fat chick?

There HAS to be porn of a guy and a tranny double teaming a fat chick.

Don't fail me internet...brb

[Beeblebrox]

To the OP: you should add something to your explanation, that forces you to choose between one of them. For instance: you signed a contract without reading it and now are a participant of a new Japanese game show, current national sensation, where you must choose between options "A" and "B" or face imminent death by ape rape.

[Vanno]

Tranny for sure.

[junkoe]

Once again I am spared the choice.

This pretty much. I am not so hard up that I'll fuck anything that walks.

They are both unattractive because of there features. I would fuck neither.

The features that make them both equally unattractive to me would be:

The man because I can see the man in his face.

The chic cause she is extremely obese.

I cannot choose one over the other, because I am attracted to neither.

[Jebsta16]

go with the chick no matter what. i am surprised that it is more for the she-male. no matter what you are swapping spit with a dude and sexing a dude. to me that is gay no matter how you want to splice it. shows we got 8 people here willing to be gay, thats all that tells me.

[Viluin]

To the OP: you should add something to your explanation, that forces you to choose between one of them. For instance: you signed a contract without reading it and now are a participant of a new Japanese game show, current national sensation, where you must choose between options "A" and "B" or face imminent death by ape rape.

Ape rape for sure.

[Ak0Mg0]

go with the chick no matter what. i am surprised that it is more for the she-male. no matter what you are swapping spit with a dude and sexing a dude. to me that is gay no matter how you want to splice it. shows we got 8 people here willing to be gay, thats all that tells me.

And if the poll was public, you would be sending them dirty PMs. ;)

[Grisu]

the fat chick is still female and hasent been screwed with. but the other 1 is a guy that just looks like a girl. id rather do the fat chick since a. the dude is ugly. and b. the first choice is a girl and normal.

[Caffy]

I hate you so much. It won't let me close the window that picture opened in, and it now pops up every time I load a new page.

Die in a fire.

If forced to choose between one of them, I'd kill them both, then rape the apes.

[holychicken]

Easy, fat chick.

[StainlessSteelRat]

I do not think you understand the idea behind my thread. I currently have proof that a straight male would have sex with a transvestite, and it would not make them gay. It is because the transvestite was attractive and feminine. Don't get me wrong, a average straight guy would throw them out of a window if a hot woman had a dick (most likely.) But given the choice of a attractive male to female tranny and a very un-attractive female, they will pick the tranny..

You have no proof and you are wrong. Looking at pics and saying: "tranny looks better" doesn't mean shit. Get 50 guys (1 at a time) in a room w/ a naked fat chick and a naked tranny w/ a dick and see how many of them bang either one of them...................

[Zurk]

Thing is, if you wern't told that pic B was a tranny, you'd vote her in a heartbeat and you know it. =p

[Caffy]

You have no proof and you are wrong. Looking at pics and saying: "tranny looks better" doesn't mean shit. Get 50 guys (1 at a time) in a room w/ a naked fat chick and a naked tranny w/ a dick and see how many of them bang either one of them...................

The poll results would have a huge shift if people could see the shemans penis. It's only unpleasant to look at with the meat covered up, but if you whip out the white snake people will gag.

[DoveAlexa]

You have no proof and you are wrong. Looking at pics and saying: "tranny looks better" doesn't mean shit. Get 50 guys (1 at a time) in a room w/ a naked fat chick and a naked tranny w/ a dick and see how many of them bang either one of them...................
Yes because men are so sex-crazed that even when in the presence of 49 other guys and no knowledge of any of the "ladies" they'd start fucking away...
And people say women have bad opinions of men. :P

[Layedballer]

Erm, do I HAVE to pick? I mean, can't I have both at the same time?
I refuse to vote in your bias poll

[Seesawmcgraw]

I wouldn't fuck any of them but I would let the tranny from the first example, the tranny from the second example, and the fat chick suck me off and if I had to choose between a fat chick and a tranny blowing me it would probably be the tranny because I've heard trannys are usually talented in that area

Oh and which one is more attractive the tranny in both examples

they look like women to me and as long as i don't see any male genitalia I'm not bothered

[Layedballer]

I wouldn't fuck any of them but I would let the tranny from the first example, the tranny from the second example, and the fat chick suck me off and if I had to choose between a fat chick and a tranny blowing me it would probably be the tranny because I've heard trannys are usually talented in that area

I've heard fat chicks are too. I heard they make it the best they can since they never get any so they hope you'll come back if they're great in bed.

[Spyder0527]

Looks like I'm going in the backdoor. Give me the shemale.

[Caffy]

I've heard fat chicks are too. I heard they make it the best they can since they never get any so they hope you'll come back if they're great in bed.

Right, you've heard that. :sly:

Chubby chaser.

[Layedballer]

Right, you've heard that. :sly:

Chubby chaser.

I don't like the chubbies in all honesty. But my dick doesn't discriminate, it's very politically correct.

[Apex Vertigo]

I'd say fat chick... at least it kind of looks like a woman. The last was only because the "girl" looked too much like a man and it would had made me hurl more than the actual penis.

[Apex Vertigo]

Thing is, if you wern't told that pic B was a tranny, you'd vote her in a heartbeat and you know it. =p

If the bulge wasn't so obvious perhaps, but when they are both naked side by side the dick is going to throw you off.

[Slade Trillgon]

This pretty much. I am not so hard up that I'll fuck anything that walks.

They are both unattractive because of there features. I would fuck neither.

The features that make them both equally unattractive to me would be:

The man because I can see the man in his face.

The chic cause she is extremely obese.

I cannot choose one over the other, because I am attracted to neither.

Well then we give you a double dose of viagra, gag you, tie you down, and then let both of them fuck you.

[Villageninja]

B.
Beautiful I think, but the outfit is pretty ugly IMO. I'm guessing the ribbon is signifying that you are about to open up a "package" Oh the irony...

[Steve Renolds]

For the people who say they go for the fat chick just because the tranny has a guy face, look again. That looks like a very fat man with lipstick on.

[GFH_Spike]

B, without question. Highly attractive physique. I would rather avoid the cow altogether.

[Vessol]

Shemale.

It'd be willing to take one up the backside then try to fit it through folds of fat.

[Steve Renolds]

Shemale.

It'd be willing to take one up the backside then try to fit it through folds of fat.
Just because she has a dick doesn't mean you have to be the one taking it.

[Weeking]

You can't get a real test from a picture.

[gloryhound]

B.
Beautiful I think, but the outfit is pretty ugly IMO. I'm guessing the ribbon is signifying that you are about to open up a "package" Oh the irony...

Holy fuck. That's the gayest thing anyone has ever said on forumfall, gratz.

Also, tranny again. If I'm not seeing any bits n' pieces, and they don't talk, then whatever.

[StrawberryClock]

I've heard fat chicks are too. I heard they make it the best they can since they never get any so they hope you'll come back if they're great in bed.

By your logic, the average overweight internet geek must be Casanova on a Viagra with the pelvic thrust capable of destroying concrete making love to a goddess of fertility in the Greek tradition(Not fat, unlike their northern european counterparts).

[gloryhound]

By your logic, the average overweight internet geek must be Casanova on a Viagra with the pelvic thrust capable of destroying concrete making love to a goddess of fertility in the Greek tradition(Not fat, unlike their northern european counterparts).

I only don't have sex because I'm afraid I might hurt someone with my godlike nature. :(

[Wanwo]

I got no problem sexing it up with the fat chick. As long as nobody sees me with her.

[Niles]

I hate fat people so I pick B this time.

[Honorius]

Fat chick.

[Razli]

B.

[Milo Hobgoblin]

LOL.. great stuff.

I'll have to look at the pics when I get home. Ive seen some fat chicks that were pretty damn cute.. big boobs etc..

[Vogular]

Sick minded threat maker...i will go for a handjob, it attracts me more then making a choice.

I guess the fatty...else God will punish me for having tintelings from a mismade creature, that lost his mind in the moderntimes

[Nevron]

The shemale. I'd wreck that ass.

[Konjikino]

LOL.. great stuff.

I'll have to look at the pics when I get home. Ive seen some fat chicks that were pretty damn cute.. big boobs etc..
What the fuck?

[Milo Hobgoblin]

What the fuck?

Sorry dude.. I like voluptuous women... When I was in my earyl 20's I liked those little scrawny birds you guys like.. but I prefer a woman with huge tits and a nice thick ass and some meat on her bones.

[Vanno]

Sorry dude.. I like voluptuous women... When I was in my earyl 20's I liked those little scrawny birds you guys like.. but I prefer a woman with huge tits and a nice thick ass and some meat on her bones.

I'm with you on this one, but the fat chick is more like a walrus than a human in this picture. Also, the tranny isn't exactly skeletor.

[Jezrith]

I would go with the fat chick this time around. She may be fat but she doesn't look like a dude and doesn't have a cock.


I do not think it has anything to do with being straight or gay, if you are attractive to femininity, then you are straight, if you are attractive to masculinity, then I think that would make you gay, regardless the gender.

I don't care how feminine the dude is, if he has a dick and you know it but proceed to fuck him anyway, you're gay.

[Milo Hobgoblin]

I'm with you on this one, but the fat chick is more like a walrus than a human in this picture. Also, the tranny isn't exactly skeletor.

I'll have to check em out... There is a point a chick crosses from voluptuous to FAT.. I wont touch FAT chick with a ten foot pole.. thats just fucking gross.

Problem with those shemale/tranny things is no matter how hard they try.. they still look like men. Its just fucking creepy.

And even if it was hot.. as soon as it spoke even one word and its a guys voice.. EWWWWWWW.

You'd also have to get over the fact that men and women just smell duifferent both consciously and subconsciously... if you're not gay... you probably just wont get turned on.. your brain is saying "hey.. thats a guy!"

[Vanno]

I'll have to check em out... There is a point a chick crosses from voluptuous to FAT.. I wont touch FAT chick with a ten foot pole.. thats just fucking gross.

Problem with those shemale/tranny things is no matter how hard they try.. they still look like men. Its just fucking creepy.

And even if it was hot.. as soon as it spoke even one word and its a guys voice.. EWWWWWWW.

You'd also have to get over the fact that men and women just smell duifferent both consciously and subconsciously... if you're not gay... you probably just wont get turned on.. your brain is saying "hey.. thats a guy!"

Definitely. But, I think this question doesn't really amount to a "dude or chick" question so much as a "human or other large mammal" question. She looks like the offspring of Jabba the Hut, and is dressed in a way she simply shouldn't be dressed.

[Milo Hobgoblin]

Definitely. But, I think this question doesn't really amount to a "dude or chick" question so much as a "human or other large mammal" question. She looks like the offspring of Jabba the Hut, and is dressed in a way she simply shouldn't be dressed.

is there ever a time fat chicks dont do this?

[Vanno]

is there ever a time fat chicks dont do this?

Some fat chicks know they aren't firm, and don't dress like attention whores. I commend them for that.

Usually, they don't though. For example, I saw this giant black woman wearing booty shorts and a belly shirt the other day, she had to be at least 3 and a half bills. What is worse, she thought she was the banging. It was almost comical.

[Eyrothath]

I don't care how feminine the dude is, if he has a dick and you know it but proceed to fuck him anyway, you're gay.

From the other thread, I am gonna have to disagree with you.. I agree with what Dinkfall said..

I don't really understand this fear of homosexuality thing, there's no magic in sex. A man that looks like a woman is just the same as a woman, especially if you don't know it, then not even your psyche can get in the way.

Just look into the science of what causes sexual attraction and what causes euphoria from sex. Break the mystery and stop being idiots. - Dinkfall

[Silverhandorder]

I don't understand what this shit with the neither option not being allowed. One does not have to fuck if they are not getting pleasure from it.

You are tricking poll recipients to pick a choice when they clearly do not have to.

edit: and obviously men would be drawn to attractive woman features. What else is obvious is that this time around you picked an ugly tranny that cant even trick the casual observer.

[Eyrothath]

I don't understand what this shit with the neither option not being allowed. One does not have to fuck if they are not getting pleasure from it.

You are tricking poll recipients to pick a choice when they clearly do not have to.

Ahh, but my next poll will be like that!! :D After these two threads die..

[Silverhandorder]

Ahh, but my next poll will be like that!! :D After these two threads die..

Ok that enough to make amends with me :).

[Smithy021]

From the other thread, I am gonna have to disagree with you.. I agree with what Dinkfall said..


yeah gona have to agree with u on that one..

sight its a huge turn on.. and no gay pun attend but the tranny looks cute/pretty/hot what ever compared to the mamoth.

and from a pic its would be really hard to tell thats a tranny.. with out seeing some wang.. what if she has a huge Bush?? ya never now....lol fuck i dunno...

[Viluin]

Sorry dude.. I like voluptuous women... When I was in my earyl 20's I liked those little scrawny birds you guys like.. but I prefer a woman with huge tits and a nice thick ass and some meat on her bones.

Sounds like you gained some weight over the years.

[jonyak]

Sounds like you gained some weight over the years.

or his wife did.

I know mine did.

[Eyrothath]

and from a pic its would be really hard to tell thats a tranny.. with out seeing some wang.. what if she has a huge Bush?? ya never now....lol fuck i dunno...

Tranny's don't grow hair like men, it is a effect from the female hormones, their pubic hair grows similar to that of a female, or none at all.. The only ones that sometime have a bush is the Asian "Ladyboys, as referred to by the porn industry." But other than that, they have the same exact skin as a female cause of the hormones, firm, smooth.. Basically what the hormone replacement therapy is, you replace your male hormones, with female ones. The only thing they cannot change is your bone structure, unless you take them at a very early age, like 8 or 9..

Most of them that I have seen have been shave, balls, ass-crack, no hair.. None..

[Milo Hobgoblin]

Sounds like you gained some weight over the years.

I weigh about 212lbs but after 20 years of training.. not many would call it "bad" weight LOL. I just like women to like like women and not a stick with tits.

My wife is too damn skinny.. she looks like a stick with tits.. I want her to put 20lbs back on.

[Milo Hobgoblin]

or his wife did.

I know mine did.

bad weight or good weight? Some women really do look better with a little weight on em..

[jonyak]

bad weight or good weight? Some women really do look better with a little weight on em..

well when I met her she was a skinny girl, but she is also 6 foot tall.

now she has weight on her, but because she is tall it looks ok... most of it went to her tits and ass... so I don't mind.

[Milo Hobgoblin]

well when I met her she was a skinny girl, but she is also 6 foot tall.

now she has weight on her, but because she is tall it looks ok... most of it went to her tits and ass... so I don't mind.

6 foot .. damn.

Sounds like you dont have much to complain about.. nothing like a tall chick with big tits and some ass on her.

[jonyak]

6 foot .. damn.

Sounds like you dont have much to complain about.. nothing like a tall chick with big tits and some ass on her.

not really...

sounds like me and you actualy have similar taste in women.

[Viluin]

I weigh about 212lbs but after 20 years of training.. not many would call it "bad" weight LOL. I just like women to like like women and not a stick with tits.

My wife is too damn skinny.. she looks like a stick with tits.. I want her to put 20lbs back on.

Don't tell her that, if you say 20 lbs she'll gain 200.

[Jangang]

what no dead chick?

I demand a recount!

[Loadafreak]

I pick the delicious manwoman thing. I wouldn't be able to hold a boner with the large whale creature.

[Jangang]

I pick the delicious manwoman thing. I wouldn't be able to hold a boner with the large whale creature.

Well you'd fully get to "Hold a boner" with the shemale... HAHAHAAAA!

I lol'd.

[Milo Hobgoblin]

Don't tell her that, if you say 20 lbs she'll gain 200.

Dude.. my wife is a workout freak.. the one thing I'll never have to worry about is her getting fat. She is in the gym 6 days a week.. eats like a bird.

[Viluin]

Dude.. my wife is a workout freak.. the one thing I'll never have to worry about is her getting fat. She is in the gym 6 days a week.. eats like a bird.

Sounds like you need to give her some more of them proteins.

[Villageninja]

Now that I look at it a little more... that shemale looks pretty similar to Julia Roberts (http://www.wallpaperbase.com/wallpapers/celebs/juliaroberts/julia_roberts_5.jpg) in the face. Her face is a little bit longer and skinnier or something but I thought it looked like somebody but I couldn't put my finger on it till just now. Puffier hair and a bit of a tan... bam.

That said... off to see transformers 2 to gaze at the perfect ass of Megan Fox.

[Ankh]

Eyrothath seems to be quite experienced in the field of shemales.

[Eyrothath]

Eyrothath seems to be quite experienced in the field of shemales.

I AM Experienced with everything, females, men, dinosaurs, transformers and metal bands.. I have the experience, in all fields, and everything. I know all..

[Barbarossa]

Fucking a fat chick that has a vag is not gay...fucking a dude who looks like a chick and has a dick is 100% completely GAY!

[Nevron]

Fucking a fat chick that has a vag is not gay...fucking a dude who looks like a chick and has a dick is 100% completely GAY!

It's not gay if you fuck the fat chick, it's beastiality. In this situation I'll take the gay route any day.

[Jezrith]

It's not gay if you fuck the fat chick, it's beastiality. In this situation I'll take the gay route any day.

Thats just because you like the cock...

[BladeSLicer]

I do not think you understand the idea behind my thread. I currently have proof that a straight male would have sex with a transvestite, and it would not make them gay. It is because the transvestite was attractive and feminine. Don't get me wrong, a average straight guy would throw them out of a window if a hot woman had a dick (most likely.) But given the choice of a attractive male to female tranny and a very un-attractive female, they will pick the tranny..

A poll amongst anonymous people on the internet, fully knowing that they won't actually have to have sex with either, is hardly "proof". I suspect 99% of those that said they'd have sex with "B" would back out as soon as they see the boys dangling between her legs.

Also, your conclusion that "a straight male would have sex with a tranvestite, and it would not make them gay" is rendered unproven by the fact that you must either choose one or the other, and there isn't a "neither" option. It is askin to telling a mother that either she allow herself to be raped or her child will be shot (most would choose the former), and then declaring that it isn't rape as some women would prefer it.

Two undesirable options with no way out. You're not going to prove what you hope to prove through using this method!

Gl though.

[Slaker]

B.........fucking hell...

[Reaper1122]

Would fuck a shemale over a fatty anyday.

[Monkeyninja]

The shemales ugly, so i guess that leaves me belly floping into the whale?:ohno:

[Nehemia]

I'd have B giving me a blowjob without any problems, as long as I can't see "her" package.

[Villageninja]

Nobody else sees the resemblance to Julia Roberts? Bah..